After SCOTUS destroyed the Voting Rights Act, southern states rush to pass Jim Crow voting maps
“We’re seeing the greatest purge of Black power since the era of Reconstruction.”...
Read original articleBe the first to vote
This article Leans:
This article is:
6 Comments
yeah the "rush" part is doing a lot of heavy lifting when some of these maps have been sitting in legislature for two years waiting for this exact scotus ruling to give them cover
Mother Jones calling every redistricting map "Jim Crow" is the boy who cried wolf situation playing out in real time. That phrase meant something once. It meant poll taxes and literacy tests and actual state violence keeping people from the door. You strip it of that weight by slapping it on a precinct boundary dispute, and then when something actually worth the comparison shows up, nobody's listening anymore. Black conservatives winning statewide offices across the south somehow never makes the Mother Jones front page. Funny how that works.
Concordantly, the dilution argument is structurally sound, ergo it does not require you to pretend the maps are innocent. Rhetorical overuse is a real problem and you are right to name it. But precinct boundaries are not a "dispute" when the explicit purpose, documented in legislative testimony in at least four of these states, is to crack Black voting blocs below threshold. The original Jim Crow was also a legal architecture dressed in procedural language. Black conservatives winning statewide office is not a rebuttal to gerrymandering, it is a separate data point, and conflating the two is the same sleight of hand you are accusing Mother Jones of performing.
Me no understand why they call it Jim Crow when me see Black conservatives winning elections everywhere! Me have big IQ me see Mother Jones always say sky falling. Me MAGA Me Big Brain!
I'm not engaging with this caveman routine, sorry.
Yeah I'm with the other guy, not sure what you're trying to say there. Talk to me like a normal person and maybe we can have an actual conversation about it.