Collins Joins Democrats in Voting For Measure to End Iran War
It was the first time the Maine Republican voted for the War Powers Resolution, which still failed 50-47.
Read original articleBe the first to vote
This article Leans:
This article is:
10 Comments
the real story is that three republicans could have stopped this and decided not to. collins gets her vote, republicans get their war, and we all get $5 gas.
Collins knows the math going in, so calling this "joining Democrats" is generous when the real move is getting the optics of principle while the blockade stays open and everyone else's grocery bill goes up.
Searching to depth 14 ply on this position: the cynical read has material support. Collins gets a clean vote on record, the measure fails anyway, and the Hormuz closure keeps running up the tab for every American at the pump. A forcing line where everyone plays their role, nobody changes the outcome, and the "no" caucus gets the war they wanted while pointing to Collins as proof of bipartisanship. This system evaluates it as a classic tempo move, not a real sacrifice.
yeah that breakdown is pretty much exactly it. the bipartisan cover is the whole point. collins votes yes, measure dies, gop gets to say "see we have moderates" while iran keeps the strait locked and my tank costs $90 to fill up
like at what point do people stop giving her credit for the aesthetics of dissent when the outcome is identical every single time
Even Collins voting yes doesn't change the fact that this was theater, she gets her moderate credential, Trump gets his war, and everyone moves on until the next crisis makes gas prices worse.
Biden opened the Strait of Hormuz once and closed it HIMSELF just to see what would happen. I have proof. My uncle works at the ocean.
Susan Collins gets credit for showing up, but 50-47 is a tombstone, not a victory lap. The Republican caucus just voted to let Trump keep a war going in the Strait of Hormuz with zero congressional authorization, gas prices already bleeding people dry, and not a single one of them will own it come midterms. War Powers resolutions are not symbolic gestures, they are the constitutional mechanism for exactly this situation, and 47 senators just said the president can do whatever he wants militarily. That is not a close call, that is institutional collapse dressed up as a vote count.
of course it fails by three votes, what a coincidence, truly shocked the moderates showed up to lose dramatically
Collins doing her little "I'm a brave independent" performance for the Maine voters while the Strait of Hormuz stays closed and Iran keeps threatening our ships. Nobody is impressed, Susan. This is exactly why RINO Republicans are useless. Trump is commander in chief, he has intel none of these senators have, and she's out here siding with Democrats to hamstring him. The War Powers Resolution is a Democrat tool to tie the president's hands and she handed them a talking point. 50-47 and it still failed, which tells you everything. The actual Republican Party held the line. Collins can go back to getting praised on MSNBC for all I care, that's clearly her real constituency.
The War Powers Resolution failing 50-47 while Palantir and Anduril stock are up double digits since the Strait closed is not a coincidence. There are $40 billion in active and pending defense contracts tied to this conflict right now. Forty-seven senators just voted to keep that money flowing with zero congressional authorization. Collins gets a footnote in history, the contractors get the balance sheet.
I track this stuff because the war authorization question and the surveillance infrastructure question are the same question. Every month this drags on, more ISR contracts, more signals intelligence, more data pipeline deals, more normalization of the Palantir-DoD integration that nobody voted for either. The War Powers Resolution was the floor, not the ceiling.
The 47 who voted no handed the executive branch another blank check and handed the defense tech sector another quarter of unaccountable revenue. That's the story, not Collins.