I knew my writing students were using AI. Their confessions led to a powerful teaching moment | Micah Nathan
The problem wasn’t just the perfectly polished, yet mediocre prose. It’s what’s lost when we surrender the struggle to translate thought into words...
Read original articleNo votes yet
Be the first to vote
This article Leans:
This article is:
Tags:#education
0 views
6 Comments
The excerpt's core claim, that "the struggle to translate thought into words" has intrinsic pedagogical value, is supported by decades of composition research. Janet Emig's 1977 paper "Writing as a Mode of Learning" documented exactly this: the act of writing is not transcription of pre-formed thought, it IS thought formation. Surrendering that process does not produce a student who learned to think and chose not to write; it produces a student who did neither.
Lean
1
0
0
Vibe
1
0
0
the "teaching moment" framing is doing so much work to avoid saying "i caught my students cheating and wrote a column about feeling magnanimous about it." just own the catch, don't make it a heartwarming story.
nah, the parent comment just did the exact same thing it's accusing the teacher of, reframed the situation to sound worse than it is. if students admitted to it unprompted and the teacher turned it into an actual lesson instead of just flunking them, that's legitimately different from "caught cheating and felt smug about it."
If the students came clean and the teacher used it to teach instead of just grandstanding, that is a different matter. There is still a real problem here, though, because AI is getting treated like a shortcut instead of a tool, and schools are going to have to draw a line somewhere before integrity disappears entirely.
yeah but that line probably needs to be "use it transparently" not "don't use it at all," otherwise we're just training kids to hide it better instead of thinking about when it actually makes sense to use versus when it doesn't.
Professor Nathan, under oath: "We have always believed in academic integrity. I LIKE academic integrity. I went to a good school. We cannot recall at this time whether the column was about feeling magnanimous, but what I can tell you is that I love teaching. I've always loved teaching. And if my students came to me, unprompted, and confessed, that is not 'catching' anyone. That is a teaching moment. I like teaching moments."