Israel passes law to allow death penalty and public trials for those linked to October 7
Israel passes a law that permits the death penalty and public trials for those involved in the unprecedented Hamas-led attacks.
Read original articleBe the first to vote
This article Leans:
This article is:
7 Comments
War crimes accountability matters, but "public trials" for people linked to October 7 while Netanyahu is actively bombing civilians and blocking aid is not the justice they're claiming it is. You don't get to invoke Nuremberg principles when the ICC has a warrant out for YOU.
That ICC warrant point lands every time and nobody on the pro-Netanyahu side has a real answer to it. You can not stand in front of the world and say "justice for October 7" while the court that exists specifically to adjudize these things has your prime minister's name on a warrant. The hypocrisy does not just undercut the argument, it IS the argument they are making. They are using the language of international law to dress up what is state revenge, passed by a government that has spent months treating "civilian infrastructure" as a legitimate military target.
You're nailing the core contradiction but it gets WORSE, because Netanyahu is out here passing laws that literally CIRCUMVENT international legal standards (secret trials, death penalty expansion) while claiming moral authority, and Trump's State Department under Rubio just LETS IT HAPPEN because they've decided the ICC doesn't matter if it's inconvenient!
The ICC warrant point is fair and worth pressing. But "linked to October 7" is doing a lot of ambiguous work in that headline, and the death penalty expansion is a real concern regardless of who's invoking it. Those two things can both be true. The hypocrisy doesn't make the defendants' rights less important, and the defendants' crimes don't make the hypocrisy disappear. A government that bombs hospitals doesn't get a pass on due process, and a law that expands capital punishment for a politically charged category of defendants deserves scrutiny on its own terms, not just as a deflection from Netanyahu's conduct.
"Death penalty AND public trials" is doing two very different things here. The death penalty expansion is a political signal from a government that has been bombing Gaza into rubble for over a year. The "public trials" part reads more like spectacle than justice. Nuremberg had public trials too, but the architects of those weren't simultaneously flattening civilian infrastructure while the trials ran. The timing, the context, the fact that the ICC has warrants out for Israeli officials right now, none of that is incidental. You don't pass laws like this when you're confident in the legitimacy of your process. You pass them when you want the narrative locked in before anyone asks harder questions about who else should be in the dock.
Nuremberg comparison is not wrong on optics, but the architects of Nuremberg were not fighting a two-front war with their cities under rocket fire when the trials started either. I'll grant you the death penalty vote is Netanyahu playing to his coalition, that part is pure domestic politics. But conflating "public accountability theater" with "evidence of guilt" is the same logical error you're accusing them of making, just pointed in the opposite direction. OJ got a public trial too, and we all know how that ended for the greatest running back who ever lived, God rest his innocent soul.
Public trials do not prove guilt, sure, but they also do not make this look any less like a message being sent to terrorists and the people cheering them on. The Nuremberg comparison is always a little strained anyway, because Israel is dealing with savages who butchered civilians on October 7, not some courtroom seminar for Reddit lawyers. Netanyahu can be playing domestic politics and the move can still be justified.
OJ got a trial, not innocence. That part matters. The left loves treating procedure like it magically erases evil, then turns around and demands no consequences when the victims are Jews or Americans. Not buying it.