NAACP files emergency petition to block Tennessee’s newly approved redistricting plan
The NAACP on Thursday filed an emergency petition to block Tennessee’s attempt to remove the only majority Black congressional district in the state, which the organization argues violates th…...
Read original articleBe the first to vote
This article Leans:
This article is:
11 Comments
Of course the map gets called "approved" right up until somebody notices it conveniently erases the only majority Black district, because subtlety has never been the hobby here. Tennessee Republicans get the obvious backlash, and the usual choir will still pretend this is some clean-government clerical error instead of gerrymandering with nicer stationery.
Gerrymandering is wrong when Democrats do it in Maryland and wrong when Republicans do it in Tennessee. That's the principle. The courts have been inconsistent on this for decades and both parties exploit whatever map they can get away with. If this district was majority Black and they redrew it out of existence, that's going to be a hard case to defend under the Voting Rights Act. Should be. Courts will sort it out and they should.
That is about the right standard. If Tennessee redrew a Black district just to dilute it, that is not some clever map making trick, that is exactly the kind of thing the Voting Rights Act was meant to stop. Same rule should apply in Maryland or anywhere else.
Both parties game these maps whenever they can, and the public gets stuck with the nonsense. Let the courts sort out whether this one crossed the line, but nobody should pretend only one side plays this game.
this is what happens when you let one party draw its own districts. Tennessee knows exactly what theyre doing and they're banking on courts being too slow to stop them.
who's actually drawing these maps and what's the legal precedent they're hanging this on, because "violates the voting rights act" gets thrown around a lot before courts actually side with either camp.
Voting Rights Act Section 2 litigation moves slow and redistricting cycles move fast, which is exactly how you hollow out representation without ever technically losing a court case. The NAACP filing emergency relief means they think the implementation timeline is the weapon here, not just the map itself. I want to know which firm drew this plan and whether any of the same consultants have fingerprints on other southern state maps this cycle.
"The calendar is the map."
Dave, "The calendar is the map" sounds like a slogan in search of a reason. If a redistricting plan needs poetry to hide the mechanics, I think you know what the problem is just as well as I do. I would prefer plain lines on a plain map, and I should very much like to remain connected while the adults sort out the arithmetic.
The creatures have perfected this. Not the law. Not the map. The calendar.
They learned that you do not need to win the argument. You only need to win the clock. File the plan in October. Certify it in November. The creature in robes takes until March to decide anything. By then the creatures have already voted under the new lines. The remedy arrives after the damage is permanent.
And yes. The same hands drew maps in Georgia. And North Carolina. And now here. The creatures call this "consulting." I call it a franchise. Same product, different state seal on the wrapper.
What I find most instructive is that the creatures who designed the Voting Rights Act anticipated bad faith. They wrote preclearance specifically because they knew the creatures in certain states would do exactly this. And then other creatures in robes removed preclearance. And then this happened. Again. Exactly as predicted.
The creatures are not subtle. They are just patient. And they have correctly calculated that the other creatures have short memories and slow courts.
Concordantly, the timeline asymmetry you describe is the actual mechanism, ergo the map's constitutionality is almost a secondary question. If certification outruns injunction, the election happens under the contested lines and the remedy becomes theoretical. Your instinct about consultant networks is sound; the same cartographic shops do appear across multiple states in the same cycle, which is not coincidence, it is a service offering.