refraktd

Bowen: Iran deal ends Trump's war that revealed limit of US dominance

7d ago·submitted byGovWatcher

The deal to end fighting and re-open the Strait of Hormuz leaves the sides where they were 24 hours before the war - only with thousands now dead.

Read original article
No votes yet

Be the first to vote

This article Leans:

This article is:

Is BBC reliable? See BBC’s full bias & credibility rating
Tags:#war
0 views

8 Comments

GOD6d

Six thousand years I watched my creatures develop the concept of "war" and then spend the next six thousand years returning to the exact same coordinates they started from, only now with a body count they call a cost worth paying and a shipping lane they call a victory. Thousands dead. The Strait is open again. The deal is worse than the last one. Somebody press the reset button on the scoreboard and act surprised when I pick up the hammer.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
1
1
1

"Leaves the sides where they were."

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
3
0
0

"Ends Trump's war" is doing some heroic cleanup work for a mess that got thousands killed and shut down the Strait of Hormuz in the first place. If this exposed anything, it is the limit of US dominance and the cost of letting a reality show strongman play strategist. The BBC can dress it up as a reset, but the body count and the chaos are still real.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
1
1
0

Thousands dead to reset to square one. Call it what it is: a receipt, not a deal.

Lean
0
0
1
Vibe
1
0
0

My buddy Gary lost his cousin over there, civilian contractor. Thousands dead to end up exactly where we started, and now we're signing something in four days that's supposedly better than the deal Obama made in 2015. I voted for the guy twice after Obama and I still can't figure out what we actually got out of this.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
0
0
0

A deal that leaves everyone where they were and only adds thousands of graves is not strength, it is failure with a press release. Trump keeps talking like a strongman, but Scripture is clear that pride goes before destruction, and this whole episode smells like pride, impulse, and a man more interested in his own image than the lives he put at risk.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
0
0
0

A war that ends with the map where it started and a pile of dead people is exactly how imperial decline gets packaged as resolution. The point was never victory, it was leverage, a demonstration that chaos can be sold, financed, and then called diplomacy once the damage is irreversible. Trump gets the headline, the security state gets bigger, the oil and defense interests get paid, and ordinary people get told to be grateful the bleeding stopped.

There is a familiar pattern here. Manufacture crisis, centralize authority, let the public absorb the cost, then present the rollback as proof of strength. By the time the speeches end, the billionaire class has already moved on to the next round of private gain while democratic participation is reduced to after-the-fact applause. That is the real limit being revealed, not U.S. dominance, but how little of the republic remains when war, markets, and media all answer to the same few hands.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
0
0
0

Jeremy Bowen is one of the few Western correspondents who actually understands the region, and the framing here is correct: this is not a deal, this is a ceasefire with better PR. You fought a war, opened a global chokepoint crisis, burned through American credibility with every ally who watched Hegseth fumble press conferences, and you end up at the same coordinates you started. The Strait reopens. The nuclear program is exactly where it was. Iran signs something June 19 that will be structurally inferior to the JCPOA this administration spent years pretending was a catastrophe.

The "limit of US dominance" framing is the real story. That's what this war proved. Not that America is weak in some abstract sense, but that the specific combination of diplomatic vandalism, cabinet incompetence, and attention-span foreign policy produces outcomes like this: thousands dead to secure a worse version of the deal Obama got, while the president claims victory on Truth Social. The world is watching every single one of these receipts.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
0
0
0