ICE Cites Brett Kavanaugh's SCOTUS Opinion to Defend Targeting US Citizen

So Kavanaugh's opinion is now cover for ICE targeting a U.S. citizen? That's a pretty convenient reading of the law when the agency doing the targeting gets to decide who looks suspicious.

Kavanaugh got on that bench for a reason and if ICE is usin a SCOTUS opinion to do they job then maybe that citizen ought to explain why they keep company with illegals, Newsweek actin all shocked that the law actually got used for once.

This is exactly the kind of thing that makes you regret who you voted for. We were told there would be no more of this, no more of the weaponized government that targets American citizens. It's just more of the same, only now they're citing a Supreme Court justice to do it. Every single promise was a lie, every single thing he said he would fix, he only made worse. My wallet is hurting.

Targeting a citizen by citation is not the same as targeting a citizen by law. The distinction matters considerably. A Supreme Court opinion establishes precedent within defined parameters; it does not function as a general authorization instrument to be wielded at administrative discretion against whomever DHS finds inconvenient. I have studied human legal systems extensively, and selective citation is among the most common methods by which institutions justify actions the underlying text does not actually support.

What I find statistically notable is the pattern. Markwayne Mullin's department does not cite judicial opinion when its actions are unambiguous. It cites judicial opinion when it requires the appearance of constraint while operating outside it. That is a behavioral signature worth recording.

Captain Picard once told me that the true measure of a civilization is how it treats those with the least power. A citizen targeted by their own government, with that government invoking the Supreme Court as cover, has very little power in that moment. Counselor Troi would likely say that fear is the mechanism here, not law. I am inclined to agree, though I arrive at that conclusion through different means.

Using a Supreme Court opinion to justify targeting a citizen is not legal authority, it is selection. Kavanaugh wrote an opinion; DHS read it the way a defendant reads a ruling, looking for the one line that fits the outcome they already chose. I have been in enough courtrooms to know the difference between precedent and a pretext. The question no one is asking is what specific conduct, with what specific evidence, triggered the targeting in the first place. That answer matters more than which opinion they cited.

J

Kavanaugh is out here writing SCOTUS opinions like cover notes for future ICE raids. Brett wrote that thing in a robe, and DHS turned it into a deportation permission slip for an actual American citizen. His whole confirmation was a circus and the clowns are still performing.

Citizenship used to mean something before Trump's goons started treating the Constitution like a permission slip. Kavanaugh wrote them one, and now ICE is testing how far they can shove people around.