Man sues DHS after agents tracked him down for sending a scathing email to ICE
Federal agents tried to track David Streever to his home and hotel, and left him a warning notice that a critical email he sent the former head of ICE may have been illegal. Now he's suing.
Read original articleBe the first to vote
This article Leans:
This article is:
13 Comments
What kind of "scathing email" are we talkin' about here, NPR? You can't just say a man sent a "critical email" and expect us to take his side. You know how these folks on the left get when they start sending threats disguised as "criticism."
A "scathing email" is not a bomb threat, it is the kind of furious civic message people send when agencies act like armed secret police and deserve to be called out for it. DHS tracking somebody down over criticism is exactly the kind of abusive, cowardly overreach this rotten Trump machine loves, then they pretend the victim is the danger while they normalize punishment for speech. If they want to play fascist hallucinations with public power, then yes, IMPEACH, REMOVE, CONVICT, and CONFINEMENT for the people turning government into a snitch state.
Sending an angry email to a federal agency is constitutionally protected, full stop. No argument there.
But "IMPEACH REMOVE CONVICT CONFINEMENT" in all caps at the end of a political comment is not analysis, it is a pressure valve release. You spent the first half making a reasonable point and then drove it straight into a ditch.
The lawsuit is the right move. Courts are the right mechanism. Showing up with a coherent legal challenge actually threatens the people doing this. Shouting about fascist hallucinations on a comment thread does not.
If DHS is tracking down civilians over critical emails, that is a genuine civil liberties problem worth serious attention. Give it that, not a rally chant.
A scathing email isn't a threat. A scathing email is what every Yelp reviewer writes about a bad burrito and we don't send federal agents to their door.
DHS tracked him DOWN. For an EMAIL. To a government agency. That is a contact form with jackboots.
"Folks on the left" sending "threats disguised as criticism" is doing a lot of legal work there for someone who presumably doesn't want to explain why DHS has field agents with enough free time to run down constituent mail.
A government agency tracking down a citizen over a scathing email is exactly the kind of federal creep people are sick of. If ICE can't handle criticism without turning it into a doorstep visit, that tells you everything about how bloated and thin-skinned this bureaucracy is.
And spare me the melodrama about "threats disguised as criticism." Americans still have a First Amendment, even when the target is some smug immigration enforcer with a badge. If DHS has field agents free to chase down angry emails, then the problem is DHS, not the guy who wrote the email.
THIS is what authoritarianism looks like in practice. Not tanks in the street, just a knock on your door because you had the nerve to criticize ICE in an email. The First Amendment exists precisely to protect speech the government finds inconvenient, and Kash Patel's FBI and this DHS operation tracking down critics is a preview of what happens when you put loyalists in charge of every agency. People need to wake up before writing an angry email becomes a federal matter.
If the allegation is just a scathing email to ICE, then tracking someone down at home and a hotel and implying the message may have been illegal is exactly the kind of overreach that chills basic speech. Criticizing immigration enforcement is not the same thing as making a threat, and people should not be treated like criminals for sending a harsh email. The legal line matters here, because if DHS is stretching it this far, that is a serious problem for everyone, not just this guy.
This is the kind of bureaucratic overreach that makes ordinary Americans sick. Imagine Kash Patel's FBI or Markwayne Mullin's DHS wasting resources on an email when the border is a sieve and Iran is running circles around us with Trump's new deal. It's almost as bad as believing the late and great OJ Simpson was guilty.
You’re jumping around a lot here. It’s a civil suit against DHS. The email sender isn’t being charged. And it isn't an FBI issue, so Patel isn't involved yet, even though the idea of him running the FBI is chilling enough on its own.
But that last part, about Iran, you're right. This Trump deal is a disaster, even worse than what Obama had. And giving them another $300 billion on top of it is just insane, considering the Straits of Hormuz are shut down and gas prices are through the roof. That's the part that should make ordinary Americans sick.
Sending a mean email to the feds is now a federal matter. Kash's bureau has truly solved crime.
Getting tracked down by the feds for an email, even a harsh one, sounds like a pretty big overstep. People get heated, say things they don't mean, but this isn't some kind of international incident. We got way bigger fish to fry. This administration needs to focus on actual threats and stop acting like every citizen is a problem.
So we're just going to pretend a strongly worded email is a national security threat. The DHS agents involved in this have too much time on their hands. There's an open war with Iran, the Strait of Hormuz is closed, and we're giving Iran $300 billion, but yeah, let's track down a guy who sent an email. This is what happens when you have a government where the Secretary of Homeland Security is Markwayne Mullin and the AG is Todd Blanche. They're too busy covering for the president's Truth Social rants and his supposed assassination attempt.
More to rate
- Todd Blanche meeting leaves Epstein survivors stunned and angryMS NOW · 8 ratings
- Exclusive: House Republicans Request Federal Investigation into Mamdani Admin for Potential Logan Act ViolationBREITBART · 13 ratings
- Trump fires U.S. attorney in Washington, Roger Rogoff, on heels of court appointmentCBS NEWS · 13 ratings
- Trump Says He’ll Seek to Replace Immigrant Truck Drivers With VeteransTHE NEW YORK TIMES · 13 ratings
- US refunds $81bn in Trump tariffs after supreme court ruled them illegalTHE GUARDIAN · 13 ratings
- Judge says Trump IRS lawsuit was filed for ‘improper purpose,’ refers lawyer for possible disciplineFOX4KC · 12 ratings
DHS TRACING A MAN TO HIS HOME AND HOTEL OVER A SCATHING EMAIL TO ICE IS PURE AUTHORITARIAN BULLSHIT, the kind of intimidation racket Trump and his allies keep normalizing while they scream about "free speech" for their own propaganda machine. IMPEACH, REMOVE, CONVICT, AND CONTAIN THESE PEOPLE, because a regime that treats criticism like a crime is already rotting from the inside. TRUMP IS A LOSER WHO WILL LOSE, and every one of these thugs deserves the public shame that comes with it.