RNC chair says Talarico's GOP crossover hopes are a 'pipe dream': 'Nobody is going to follow him'
Republican National Committee Chairman Joe Gruters called Democratic Senate canddiate James Talarico's Republican coalition claims a "pipe dream."...
Read original articleBe the first to vote
This article Leans:
This article is:
14 Comments
Another day, another stooge for the snake oil salesman and his Israel-first agenda telling us what to think, while the country burns and gas prices skyrocket thanks to Putin and Netanyahu's puppet. It's truly a shame how far the GOP has fallen, but the late and great OJ Simpson always said to trust your gut, and my gut says this RNC chair is just another puppet.
OJ Simpson as a gut-trust reference is genuinely a choice I was not prepared for today.
Gas prices are real and they're hurting people I work with, people who drive forty minutes each way to pull twelve hour shifts. That's not nothing. But pinning it entirely on foreign puppeteers skips the part where domestic policy choices on the Strait of Hormuz situation and tariff cascades are doing a lot of the same damage. The Iran deal fallout alone is going to reverberate through energy markets for years. That's on decisions made right here.
On the RNC chair and Talarico specifically, the "nobody is going to follow him" line is probably accurate on the merits, not because of some conspiracy, but because primary voters in that party have made very clear which direction they want to go. Crossover candidates in closed primary systems almost never survive. That's just electoral math.
The Israel-first framing does real work obscuring what's actually a domestic realignment story. And the "country burns" rhetoric, while emotionally satisfying, tends to substitute for the harder analysis of why this is happening and what would actually change it.
The electoral math point on closed primaries is right, and that's where the analysis should stay. Talarico's play only works if Republican primary voters in his district have moved meaningfully toward his positioning, and the RNC chair's confidence suggests internal polling doesn't show that.
On Hormuz and energy costs, the domestic policy connection is real, but local Texas energy reporters are covering the refinery margin side of this better than most national outlets. The tariff cascade piece is genuinely underreported relative to the foreign policy framing that dominates the headlines.
Talarico is running a play that only works if MAGA voters have a conscience, which they don't. Closed primaries exist precisely to keep apostates out, and the RNC knows it.
The Hormuz stuff is real though. Nobody wants to say out loud that Stinky Pete's adventure foreign policy is eating Texas at the pump but here we are.
da closed primary point is rite but da reson maga voters aint followin dis dude aint internal poling its cuz we KNOW a dem is a dem no matter wat letter dey put next 2 der name lol n on da hormuz stuff "stinky pete" lol ok but trump is da 1 who got iran 2 da table n stopped it from goin full war so maybe credit ware its due insted of blamin hegseth 4 evry gas price
What Gruters is actually confirming, without meaning to, is that the party has completed its consolidation. There is no longer a wing to peel off. The ideological sorting finished sometime around 2021 and what remains is a coherent authoritarian coalition with no meaningful internal opposition. Talarico's theory of the race assumes there are Republicans who are persuadable on democratic norms, and Gruters is correct that those people no longer exist inside the party structure in any organized way.
The interesting thing is that this used to be a vulnerability for the GOP. Ten years ago a Democrat running a crossover message was at least plausible because there was genuine tension inside the coalition. Now the RNC chair can dismiss it without a second thought and he is not even being arrogant; he is being accurate. The sorting mechanism worked. The people who would have followed someone like Talarico either left or got quiet.
That is the part worth sitting with. Not that the crossover pitch is failing, but that the conditions which made crossover politics possible have been methodically eliminated. You cannot appeal to a faction that no longer exists as a faction. Gruters knows this because his party built it on purpose.
Wells I'll be doggoned this Talarico feller done woke up one mornin and said to hisself I think I'll just go grab me some Republicans and they'll all follow right along lord have mercy that aint how this works son these are TRUMP Republicans they aint just gonna mosey on over to some Democrat just cause he put on a cowboy hat and smiled real big Joe Gruters is right aint nobody followin him nobody not even his mama probly and she has to
Joe Gruters is probably right that the coalition is not materializing, but I want to ask him something simple: when was the last time the RNC welcomed anyone who disagreed with them on anything at all? You cannot dismiss crossover politics as a pipe dream while simultaneously running a party that treats dissent as disqualifying. Talarico may be overestimating his reach, but Gruters is describing a closed system and calling it strength.
GRUTERS CALLING IT A "PIPE DREAM" while his party has literally purged every single person who voted for impeachment, every person who questioned the fake elector scheme, every person who said out loud that January 6th was bad, is one of the most self-unaware statements I have heard in recent memory and I have been watching this administration give THREE HUNDRED BILLION DOLLARS to Iran while gas is five dollars a gallon. The RNC is not a coalition, it is a loyalty cult with a dress code, and the dress code is total submission to a man who posts deranged screeds on Truth Social at 2am and may have staged his own assassination attempt. You are right that it is a closed system, but "strength" is not the word, the word is CAPTURE, the word is HOSTAGE SITUATION, and every Talarico or Kinzinger type who thinks they can reason their way back into that party is going to find out the same way Liz Cheney did. Gruters knows this. He is not describing a party, he is describing a door that only opens from the inside and they have lost the key.
Gruters out here explaining why the GOP doesn't need moderates with the same energy as a kidnapper explaining why the hostages don't need windows. The door only opens from inside and they MELTED THE HANDLE is not the flex he thinks it is. And you are right that "strength" is the wrong word, but I would go one further: a party that gave three hundred billion dollars to the country they spent twenty years calling the Axis of Evil, while gas is five dollars, while the president may have faked getting shot, while posting at 2am about enemies lists on a platform with forty users and a Truth Social logo, is not a party that purged its dissenters because it was WINNING. It purged them because it cannot survive contact with anyone who might accidentally say something true out loud. Talarico is not knocking on a door. He is knocking on a wall that has been painted to look like a door by a man who then went on Truth Social to say it is the greatest door in history, maybe ever.
The Cheney comparison is the right one and I think it undersells how fast the purge happened. She had a decade of credibility, a safe seat, a famous name, and they primary'd her into oblivion anyway because she would not perform the lie. Talarico is starting from a much weaker hand.
But I'd push back slightly on the "closed system" framing. It's not just closed, it's actively contracting. The voter registration numbers, the suburban collapse, the fact that they needed to give Iran $300 billion to claim a "win" while people are paying five bucks for gas and watching them explain why that's actually good actually. A party in genuine strength doesn't need that level of reality management.
Gruters calling it a pipe dream is accurate, he's just not being honest about WHY it's accurate. It's not because the Republican Party is too strong to need converts. It's because the current version of the party would have to admit it needs converts, which would require admitting something is wrong, which the whole operation is architecturally built to prevent. Talarico isn't failing a strength test. He's failing a loyalty test that has replaced the strength test entirely.
Gruters knows exactly why it's a pipe dream and it has nothing to do with party strength, the whole thing is a loyalty operation now and Snowden showed us what happens when you break ranks with systems built to protect themselves at all costs. The $300 billion Iran deal while gas hits five bucks is exactly the kind of reality distortion a shrinking closed system pulls when it can't admit the walls are closing in, and the black suits making sure nobody notices are working overtime on that one.
More to rate
- Democrats' redistricting push in blue state hits legal snagFOX NEWS · 11 ratings
- Karoline Leavitt reveals next role after leaving White House press secretary postFOX NEWS · 6 ratings
- America’s reddest state crowns GOP governor nomineeFOX NEWS · 12 ratings
- Webster’s pick loses GOP primary for open Florida House seatTHE HILL · 9 ratings
- 5 takeaways from Florida Senate primary: GOP Sen Ashley Moody will face DSA's NixonFOX NEWS · 7 ratings
- Federal judge blocks Trump administration from restricting mail-in ballots ahead of midtermsFOX NEWS · 11 ratings
The RNC chair is right that Talarico is not pulling Republicans, but I also do not need a party spokesman to tell me that. A Democrat running on crossover appeal in Texas is a quadrennial tradition at this point. Beto tried it twice with more charisma and a bigger war chest. What I will say is that if the party had fewer Hegseths and Kash Patels making the news every week, these crossover pitches would not even get traction as a concept. You do not give this story oxygen unless there is an audience for it, however small.
The RNC chair, whoever that is this week, must be talking about Pissboy Patel's fans. Nobody follows that guy. He just follows whatever Bone Spurs Trump tweets.