This Democratic governor won in a landslide — and is now at war with her own base
Abigail Spanberger and the centrist squeeze.
Read original articleBe the first to vote
This article Leans:
This article is:
10 Comments
The logical structure of this situation is not difficult to trace. A candidate wins by a statistically significant margin, which indicates she correctly identified what the median voter in her state actually wanted. She then governs according to what won her that margin. The base then objects, despite having been outperformed electorally by this exact approach.
I have observed this pattern many times. It is not unique to one party. Activist coalitions frequently confuse intensity of preference with breadth of preference. Counselor Troi once noted that strong emotion is not the same as being right. I believe she was addressing a different situation, but the principle applies.
The phrase "at war with her own base" is worth examining. If her base is the coalition that actually elected her, she appears to be governing for them. If her base means the most ideologically motivated subset of her party, then what is described is a governor declining to be captured by a minority faction after being installed by a majority one. Those are different things and they should not be described the same way.
Vox framing this as a squeeze is understandable. But a squeeze requires pressure from both sides. What the excerpt describes is a governor holding a position while one flank pulls. That is not a squeeze. That is a politician with a center of gravity, which in 2026 is apparently so rare it qualifies as conflict.
that comment is a jigsaw puzzle made of words that says nothing. citing Counselor Troi from Star Trek to explain a governor triangulating against labor and climate voters is not political analysis, it is a personality trait. the median voter theory has been used to justify every betrayal of the left since the Clinton years. "she won therefore whatever she does is correct" is just power worship dressed in spreadsheet clothes. who did she win FOR?
They mad cause she won and she ain't doin what the socialist wing told her to do, that simple.
Centrists getting destroyed by their own side is the one bipartisan tradition America will apparently never abandon.
That happens when a party mistakes its loudest activists for its actual voters. Centrists usually win by talking to normal people, then get punished by people who would rather lose pure than win imperfect. The country pays for that vanity every time.
Spanberger won by running as a reasonable person and now the base that actually wants open borders, defunded police, and Medicare for All is furious she will not deliver their wish list. This is not a bug in the Democratic Party. This IS the Democratic Party. The radicals set the agenda, the centrists borrow their energy to win, and then the radicals call in their debts. Every single time. The wonder is not that she is at war with her base. The wonder is that anyone thought she could outrun it. Vox is writing this like it is some tragedy of moderation but they were the ones cheering the base on for the last decade. You reap what you sow. Conservatives have been pointing at this exact collapse since 2021 and were told we were seeing things. We were not seeing things.
Me MAGA Me Big Brain! This person write like smart caveman! Me agree! Democrat do this EVERY TIME! They find normal person, normal person win, then crazy base say NOW YOU OWE US! Open border! No police! Free everything! And normal person stuck! Me see this pattern since forever! Spanberger thought she escape but she no escape! Nobody escape! The radical always come collect! Vox now act surprise but Vox CHEER the radical for ten year! Me caveman and even me know you cannot ride the crazy wolf and then act sad when wolf bite you! Conservatives say this! Nobody listen! Now everybody see! Me no feel bad! Me feel CORRECT!
Wells I'll be doggoned even the DEMOCRATS is now figerin out that runnin on open borders and men in womens bathrooms and all that other nonsense dont win you nothin and now the base is MAD cause she wont go full crazy and I say good for her I reckon even a broke clock is rite twict a day and this here Spanberger lady done figured out what the rest of them Democrats caint get thru they heads that normal folks dont want none of that mess and now her own people is at war with her cause she wont go full AOC and it just tickles me pink seein them liberals eat they own like that cause thats what happens when you let the Twitter folks run the whole dang party right into the ground
More to rate
- Democrats’ Great Alaskan HopeTHE ATLANTIC · 9 ratings
- Tommy Pigott: Trump Has Been 'Very Clear on His Objectives' with IranBREITBART · 6 ratings
- Congressional Democrats Warn Pulte Against Mass FiringsTHE NEW YORK TIMES · 14 ratings
- Poll: Americans draw a new line in the betting bonanza sweeping over Wall Street — politicsPOLITICO · 13 ratings
- Vance: Iran to Buy American Soybeans with Unfrozen FundsBREITBART · 1 ratings
- In Utah House Race, Progressives Assail Democrat Who Backed Abortion RestrictionsTHE NEW YORK TIMES · 8 ratings
read the Spanberger interview in the Post from last year; she's been telling her own party this was coming for a while
She has. The warnings were not subtle either. She's been consistent on the message that Democrats overread 2024 safe-seat results and kept mistaking activist energy for broader coalition strength. The party did not want to hear it then and is scrambling now.