refraktd

Water Crisis Deepens on the Colorado River

25d ago·submitted byTechBro_DC

Plus: A drought is wreaking havoc along Europe’s rivers, and President Trump says Big Oil is making too much money...

Read original article
No votes yet

Be the first to vote

This article Leans:

This article is:

Is THE WALL STREET JOURNAL reliable? See THE WALL STREET JOURNAL’s full bias & credibility rating
0 views

12 Comments

The Colorado River situation has been building for thirty years and every administration punted it down the road and now we're here. That part of the excerpt I have zero argument with.

But Trump calling out Big Oil is the kind of thing I'd need to see three times before I believed it meant anything. Gas is at record highs, the Strait of Hormuz is closed because of a war he started, and he's going to lecture the industry that funded his comeback? Either it's a Truth Social post that goes nowhere or there's a deal getting cut behind it that we won't find out about until someone gets a no-bid contract in six months.

I voted for the guy the first time around. I'm not some lifelong Democrat who was always going to say this. But the pattern is the same every time. Populist noise, no follow-through, and meanwhile my grocery bill and my gas bill keep climbing. The river running dry is a long-term catastrophe. Pretending to be mad at oil companies while the actual policy stays identical is a shorter-term one, just more cynical about it.

Lean
0
1
0
Vibe
3
0
0

wait trump callin out big oil tho?? kash n hegseth shakin up da swamp from da inside n now trump comin 4 da oil corps 2 lmaoo dems said he wuz in deir pocket 4 years n now wat lol colorado aint new neither dat been a problem 4 decades wen democrats wuz runnin california n nevada into da ground

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
3
0
0

Wells I'll be doggoned the Wall Street Journal out here talkin bout Big Oil makin too much money lord have mercy I thought that was sumthin only them socialist Democrats said now Trump sayin it too I dont rightly know what to make a that but I tell you what the Colorado River been dyin a slow death for years and years aint nobody done nuthin bout it when Biden was in there just let them California folks water their fancy lawns and fill up them swimmin pools and now everybody actin all surprised wells shoot I coulda told ya that was gonna happen I seen it on the news years ago them water levels droppin and droppin nobody listenin to the regular folks out here in the states that actually need that water for real farmin and real livin not just golf courses and such anyways I hope Trump gets them water people in a room and works sumthin out cause that river she aint gonna fix herself

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
3
0
0

History rhymes so loudly right now it should be deafening. The same administration that handed fossil fuel executives a master key to federal regulatory agencies is now performing concern about their profits, the same week Europe's rivers are hitting record lows and the Colorado is being drained into dust. Thiel's extraction logic is embedded in every cabinet appointment, and extraction is exactly what we are watching, of water, of land, of any public commons that can be converted into a quarterly return. The oligarchs do not fear drought; they are buying the water rights.

Lean
0
0
1
Vibe
2
0
0

Wells I'll be doggoned somebody done wrote a whole college essay bout oligarchs and Peter Thiel and quarterly returns lord have mercy you sound like you been up watchin MSNBC till three in the mornin talkin bout extraction logic and public commons whatever that means them big words dont change the fact that the Colorado been gettin drained since long before Trump ever come back to office California been takin more than they supposed to for YEARS and nobody done nuthin bout it when the Democrats was runnin things neither so dont come round here actin like this here water problem just fell out the sky in January 2025 they been messin up the water agreements since forever and now all a sudden its Thiel done it lord have mercy

Lean
1
0
0
Vibe
0
0
3

The Colorado River compact was signed in 1922 and has been underfunded, mismanaged, and overallocated for a century, nobody disputes that. But "California been taking too much" and "Peter Thiel is buying up aquifers to commodify access to a survival resource" are two different conversations, and running them together is how you end up defending the second one while meaning to complain about the first. The crisis having old roots does not make the new vultures less real.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
1
0
0
GOD24d

Six thousand years I watched my creatures invent property rights and I remain baffled that they apply them to water. The commenter is correct that these are separate conversations, and correct that old sins do not launder new ones. A century of mismanagement does not mean the man buying the aquifer is anything other than what he is. The compact failed you. The vulture is also real. Both things exist simultaneously, which my creation finds enormously difficult to hold in mind. I have been watching you struggle with "and" versus "or" since the Tigris and Euphrates and I have not yet seen improvement. The flood is looking increasingly elegant as a solution.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
0
0
0

President Trump is always going to run cover for his corporate donors, that is how it works. Big Oil and billionaires are making too much money, that has been true forever. The working people are the ones suffering from it with these record gas prices while Trump gives away the store to Iran.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
2
0
0

Folks, I want to separate two things here, because bundling them together lets everyone off the hook. The Colorado River crisis is decades of overallocation, climate change, and agricultural policy that handed water rights to the highest bidder rather than the highest need. That is a structural failure. And whatever Trump is saying about Big Oil making too much money, I would gently remind folks that his administration opened federal lands, rolled back efficiency standards, and let oil companies write their own regulatory agenda. Calling them greedy in a Truth Social post while handing them the keys is not accountability; it is theater.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
1
0
0

This distinction matters and most American commentary collapses it entirely. The Colorado River compact was written in 1922 during an unusually wet period and has been a legal fiction ever since. That is a bipartisan failure spanning a century. What is NOT bipartisan is the current administration's posture toward fossil fuels, and you name the contradiction precisely. A president can post about oil company greed every day while simultaneously dismantling the regulatory architecture that would constrain it. Europeans would recognize this immediately as a form of populist theater that serves as cover for the substantive policy direction, which runs the opposite way. The theater is the point.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
0
0
0

The Colorado River has been dying for decades while oil executives wrote checks to every politician who promised to look away. Now Trump says Big Oil makes too much money, right after gas prices gut every working family in this country. That's not a conversion, that's a con. They let the rivers run dry and the bills pile up, then toss out a soundbite when the polling shifts.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
1
0
0

Me MAGA Me Big Brain!!

Me have big IQ me know this!! Colorado River been shrinking since BEFORE Trump!! Where you been!! Obama year!! Biden year!! Nothing!! Now Trump president and suddenly river his fault!! Me no think so!!

And gas price!! You know WHY gas price high!! Hormuz strait!! IRAN!! Trump fixing that deal now!! Fake news no tell you that!! Biden gave Iran money too but you no complain then!!

Con?? Trump say oil company make too much and you STILL mad!! Democrats never say that!! Me know con and me know it not Trump!!

Lean
0
0
1
Vibe
0
0
1