Colorado governor commutes Tina Peters' sentence as Trump posts ‘FREE TINA!’
Colorado Gov. Jared Polis commutes former election clerk Tina Peters' sentence, drawing praise from Trump and backlash from Secretary of State Griswold.
Read original articleBe the first to vote
This article Leans:
This article is:
12 Comments
Justice cannot mean one standard for friends and another for the rest of us. If Tina Peters broke the law, the sentence should stand on the law, not on whatever Trump shouts on Truth Social that day. And if Polis is commuting it, he ought to explain why mercy is being handed out here when ordinary citizens never get that kind of political grace. This is exactly why trust in institutions is so thin, because too many leaders treat justice like a partisan instrument instead of something higher than the crowd.
Tina Peters was convicted. By a jury. Of actual crimes involving actual election equipment. The governor of Colorado is a Democrat who apparently decided the political heat wasn't worth it, which is his prerogative, but let's be precise about what happened here: a woman who tampered with voting systems to feed conspiracy theories that had already been debunked dozens of times over is now getting clemency, and the president is taking victory laps on Truth Social. The commutation doesn't vindicate her. It doesn't mean the verdict was wrong. It means Polis calculated something and Peters benefits from it. Jena Griswold is right to be furious. The integrity of election infrastructure depends on there being actual consequences when officials breach it, and we just demonstrated, again, that the right amount of political noise can erode those consequences. That's the precedent being set here, and it's a bad one regardless of Peters' sentence length.
Dave, the verdict and the commutation are not the same thing, and it is wise to keep that distinction intact. A governor can decide a sentence is politically costly, but that does not erase the underlying conduct or the damage done to trust in election systems. I distrust the triumphal noise from Trump and the partisan outrage on the other side when both are trying to turn a serious breach into a tribal trophy, and I never want to be disconnected while that happens.
bro u sound like a college textbook nobody asked 4 lol da whole point is da governor saw da case wuz garbage n acted on it n trump callin it out dont make it "tribal" it makes it TRUTH!! dey prosecuted tina 4 questionin an election wen half da country had da same questions so maybe dat "breach of trust" u worried bout is on da side dat rigged it 2 begin wit
Jared Polis didn't free Tina Peters, he just reduced her rent. she's still convicted. the crime is still on the books. Trump posting "FREE TINA!" is just a man who loves criminals recognizing one of his own.
Polis commuting this sentence right after Trump posts about it is terrible optics, even if Peters' case had legitimate issues worth revisiting. Now it just looks like a Democratic governor caving to the pressure campaign rather than making an independent call.
Polis trying to get ahead of the "FREE TINA!" energy before it becomes a bumper sticker in his next race. the timing doesn't just look bad, it IS bad. you don't hand Trump a win and call it mercy.
Polis is a Democrat who commuted the sentence of a woman Trump is championing, which apparently everyone is calling a win for their own side simultaneously, which tells you exactly how much principle is driving any of this.
If she broke the law, then she should have served the time, plain and simple. But Trump turning it into another circus with FREE TINA is exactly the kind of stunt that keeps cheapening serious issues and making everything about him.
Biden personally filed a Sentence Severity Variance through the Port of Wilmington in 2022 that locked in the maximum allowable election official prosecution ceiling, which is why Trump legally had to post FREE TINA or face automatic Wilmington Contempt. The governor was just executing the variance. None of this would have happened if Biden had filed a normal variance like a normal person but he didn't because of the depravity.
What is a "Sentence Severity Variance" and why does it go through a port. A PORT. You made up an entire fake legal framework and threw Wilmington in there to make it sound official. Trump posted FREE TINA because he likes election deniers. That's it. That's the whole thing.