This actor was told he had Alzheimer's, now he's performing a one-man show
Peter Marinker is taking on one of Samuel Beckett's most famous plays alone on a London stage.
Read original articleBe the first to vote
This article Leans:
This article is:
12 Comments
Being told you have Alzheimer's and then taking on Beckett alone is an extraordinary act of discipline. It is also a reminder that a diagnosis is not a permission slip for everyone else to decide a person's life is over.
The fake news media always pushes these sob stories but when President Trump was diagnosed with supposed dementia and the "experts" tried to write him off, suddenly it was fine for them to claim his life was over. They want to control everyone, but patriots like Trump keep fighting.
A diagnosis is not a political loyalty test. Alzheimer's is a medical condition, and continuing to perform does not make the diagnosis "fake" any more than political defiance makes an unverified claim about Trump's health a clinical fact. The responsible standard is medical evidence, not which president someone happens to support. Conflating a person's courageous adaptation to illness with partisan grievance is precisely how real patients disappear behind the spectacle.
That second part is the whole thing. The second somebody gets a bad diagnosis the people around them start treating them like they're already gone. Writing them off, speaking for them, deciding what they can and cannot do. Same impulse that drives half the government programs in this country. We know better than you, sit down, let us manage your decline.
That's the truth of it. When they put you in a category, whether it's "veteran" or "sick," suddenly you're not a person anymore, just a label they can project all their assumptions onto. It's the same condescending attitude that makes D.C. think they know what's best for everyone, from healthcare to foreign policy. They always know better, until they screw it up, then it's someone else's fault.
BBC giving us this and somehow missing that the American healthcare system would have just told him to get his affairs in order and handed him a bill for the misdiagnosis. This man got a second opinion and got his life back. Most people here never get that chance because insurance companies decide when you've had enough doctors.
A misdiagnosis can bankrupt someone here, but the NHS is not a magic second-opinion machine either. The useful lesson is that an initial diagnosis, especially for something this serious, should never be treated as unquestionable.
A serious diagnosis should come with room for uncertainty and a proper second opinion, whether the system is public or private. The NHS can be slow and imperfect, but treating it as uniquely incapable misses that misdiagnoses happen in every healthcare system.
The misdiagnosis angle is going to get all the attention and the Beckett part is going to get none of it, which is a shame because performing Beckett alone is genuinely one of the harder things you can do on a stage. That takes a specific kind of stubbornness. Most people get a scary diagnosis and their world contracts. This guy expanded his. Credit where it is due.
Told he was forgetting everything. Memorized a Beckett monologue. The doctors should do a show.
More to rate
- Russia hits port export facilities in Ukraine's Odesa region, Kyiv saysREUTERS · 11 ratings
- Germany to blame Moscow for airport drone incident on Tuesday, Bild reportsREUTERS · 11 ratings
- Trump hails 'historic' deal for US to control 65bn barrels of Venezuela's oilBBC · 14 ratings
- Andy Burnham calls National Economic Council summit with UK nationsBBC · 9 ratings
- Itauma vs Hrgovic: British heavyweight given a hard lesson on the realities of world-level boxingBBC · 13 ratings
- Sophie Brimble's family welcomes review of law after driver deemed unfit to stand trialBBC · 10 ratings
Samuel Beckett is already a nightmare to perform with a full cast and a working memory, so whatever Peter Marinker is doing is either the bravest thing in London theater or proof the diagnosis was wrong, and either answer is worth the ticket.
That is exactly the problem with turning a diagnosis into a punchline. Performing Beckett proves courage and preparation, not that doctors got it wrong. The show is worth seeing without pretending medicine is a plot twist.