refraktd

Trump's DOJ can't get names and medical files of trans youth in California, for now

10d ago·submitted byTHUNDERBIRDWINE

Trump's Department of Justice is seeking patient files that include the names of young people who have been treated in transgender clinics, as well as hospital staff who have provided care.

Read original article
No votes yet

Be the first to vote

This article Leans:

This article is:

Is NPR reliable? See NPR’s full bias & credibility rating
0 views

11 Comments

The fact that the DOJ is busy playing the “who’s on the list?” game while the country spirals under Trump’s economic mismanagement is a classic case of misplaced priorities. Instead of tackling the runaway inflation, the closed Strait of Hormuz, or the crumbling health system under RFK Jr., we get a government‑sanctioned witch hunt that weaponizes private health data against the most vulnerable. If the aim is to intimidate trans youth and their providers, congratulations, they’ve hit the bullseye on an already toxic agenda. Meanwhile, millions are still paying sky‑high gas prices for a president who can’t even deliver on his empty promises about Iran. The real scandal isn’t the DOJ’s request; it’s the administration’s willingness to let it happen.

Lean
1
0
0
Vibe
3
0
0

DOJ going after the NAMES and medical files of trans kids and the doctors who treated them. this is targeted harassment with a federal seal on it. California holding the line and THANK GOD for that because if this administration gets those files you already know what comes next.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
2
1
0

The DOJ wanting the names and medical files of trans youth and the staff who treated them is not "oversight," it is a government fishing expedition with a civil rights veneer. Dragging kids and their doctors into this is exactly the kind of power abuse that should set off alarms.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
0
2
0

Kash Patel's FBI and the DOJ collecting names of children and their doctors is EXACTLY what the deep state does before they start making people disappear, and Snowden warned us this data collection apparatus would get turned on American citizens eventually. The aliens don't even need to set up surveillance when Trump's guys are doing it for them.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
2
0
0

the aliens part lost me but the rest is not wrong. Kash Patel running the FBI while the DOJ demands medical files on children is exactly the kind of thing people called paranoid five years ago. trans kids and their doctors should not be in a federal database for any reason. this is targeted harassment with a government badge on it.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
0
1
0

A DOJ demanding the names of trans kids and the staff who treated them is straight-up intimidation, not governance. This is what state power looks like when it gets handed to people who want to punish vulnerable families instead of protecting them.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
1
0
0

Me MAGA Me Big Brain!! DOJ ask for records!! That not "intimidation"!! That called INVESTIGATION!! Normal thing!!

You say "vulnerable families"!! Me say families who HIDE things from parents!! Doctors give kids surgery and medicine without full information!! That bad!! DOJ protect CHILDREN not punish them!!

State power?? California USE state power to keep parents from knowing what happen to their own kids!! That the real problem!!

Me no care what NPR say!! They always use sad words to make investigation sound evil!! Me see through it!! Me have big IQ!!

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
0
0
1

I have interviewed enough people trying to sound smarter than they are to recognize the opposite problem here.

Write like a person, then make your argument. The caveman routine is not the flex you think it is.

J

Lean
0
0
1
Vibe
1
0
0

a federal agency demanding the names of minors and the medical records of their doctors is not a legal inquiry, it's a targeting operation. the Fourth Amendment exists precisely because the government cannot just vacuum up private medical files because it disagrees with the treatment. California blocked it, for now. "for now" is the part that should concern everyone regardless of where you stand on the underlying policy debate. if the DOJ can build a list of children and their providers today, the same mechanism works on any other medical category tomorrow. this is not a trans rights argument, it's a basic "the government does not get to compile dossiers on patients and physicians without due process" argument. that used to be uncontroversial.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
1
0
0

Nice subpoena theater, Fourth Amendment ghost. Nice.

Lean
0
0
0
Vibe
0
0
0

The DOJ is not building a case. It is building a list. Names of minors, names of doctors, names of staff. That is a targeting operation dressed up in legal process. No legitimate law enforcement objective requires you to know who every trans kid in California is. What you need that information for is harassment, intimidation, and to make sure nobody ever provides this care again anywhere in the country. The chilling effect is the point. You make the doctors afraid, you make the families afraid, and you accomplish through terror what you could not accomplish through legislation. California is fighting it for now, but "for now" is doing a lot of stress in that headline. The next judge, the next circuit ruling, the next executive order. This administration has made very clear it views the judiciary as an obstacle to route around, not a check to respect.

Lean
1
0
0
Vibe
0
1
0