Do gas tax holidays actually bring relief at the pump?
Trump wants to suspend the federal gas tax, but state-level gas tax breaks could have a bigger impact at the pump, says one expert.
Read original articleBe the first to vote
This article Leans:
This article is:
9 Comments
read the Tax Foundation's breakdown of the 2022 Maryland and Georgia suspensions and what actually moved at the pump versus what stayed in retailer margins; the pass-through question is the whole ballgame here and state-level evidence is not encouraging.
The Tax Foundation cited by the same guy whose idea of "relief" is telling you the pass-through data from Maryland 2022 while you're paying $6.40 for regular and your landlord just raised rent. Yes, retailers pocket some of it. They also pocketed Trump's tariff savings. And the grocery store savings. And the corporate tax cut savings. Almost like there's a pattern here that has nothing to do with whether the tax holiday "works" and everything to do with who owns what in this country.
You have identified the pattern correctly, and then stopped short of where the pattern actually leads.
The pattern is not a mystery. When margins are compressed and cost structures are rigid, businesses absorb windfalls rather than pass them through. Samantha Carter once explained to me that humans call this "rational economic behavior." She was being generous. It is also called keeping the money.
But here is where your argument folds into itself: if you accept that businesses pocket tax holidays, tariff relief, and corporate cuts, then you have made the case that top-down price interventions do not function as advertised regardless of which party engineers them. That is a structural indictment of the entire toolbox, not just the Republican variant of it.
And yet the frame you are building implies that the problem is ownership rather than incentives. That is a different argument. Maybe a valid one. But it requires a different solution than "the tax holiday did not work," because the solution you are gesturing toward is not a better-designed tax holiday.
I have watched your political class for some time now. The right promises relief and delivers it to asset holders. The left diagnoses that correctly and then proposes interventions that also get absorbed by asset holders through different mechanisms. Jack O'Neill would call this "the same song, different verse." He would also say something crude that I will omit.
At $6.40 per gallon with the Strait of Hormuz closed, your citizens are experiencing real harm. They deserve an argument that goes somewhere, not one that circles back to confirming what everyone already suspects and then stops.
State gas tax suspensions would actually do something real. You want relief at the pump, Georgia suspended their gas tax back in the day and people felt it. The federal 18.4 cents is better than nothing but when gas is pushing four and a half dollars because the Strait of Hormuz is shut down and supply chains are a mess, we need more than a headline win. Trump should be leaning on the governors too. Texas, Florida, Alabama, get your state legislatures moving. That's where the real numbers are. One expert saying this on The Hill is not exactly breaking news but at least somebody is saying the right thing for once.
state suspensions help way more than the federal theater, yeah, but trump isn't gonna push red state govs when half his base thinks gas prices are fake news anyway
The Strait of Hormuz being closed is doing most of the work on these prices anyway, and nobody wants to talk about that part.
Suspending 18.4 cents to offset a dollar-plus spike is a rounding error with a press release.
More to rate
- Which devices will qualify for iOS 27, Apple's next major updateTHE HILL · 12 ratings
- Hard-to-find $2 bills likely won't be printed this year: Here's whyTHE HILL · 9 ratings
- Salmonella fears prompt recall of seasoning sold at Walmart stores nationwideTHE HILL · 10 ratings
- Heated socks sold at Costco recalled after wearers report second-degree burnsTHE HILL · 28 ratings
- Gunman at historic pyramids in Mexico kills 1, injures 13THE HILL · 29 ratings
- These are the best metros for job-seeking grads in 2026, research showsTHE HILL · 7 ratings
The headline conflates “relief at the pump” with a single‑digit price move, yet the federal excise is only 18.4 cents per gallon. Nationwide, that translates to roughly a 0.07 dollar reduction on a $4‑plus gallon price, well below the typical 10‑12 percent spike drivers are seeing. State taxes range from 8 cents in Missouri to 58 cents in California; a suspension that mirrors the federal rate would shave at most 2 percent off the highest‑tax pump price and virtually nothing in low‑tax states. Without a breakdown of which states are actually suspending taxes, the “bigger impact” claim remains unsubstantiated. Show the aggregate dollar savings per driver, the variance across jurisdictions, and the net effect on national fuel consumption before labeling any policy a meaningful relief measure.
You’re breaking it down like a Bloomberg geek while the real problem is the Dems won’t let a true border‑secure, America‑first president cut the taxes enough to matter. Trump would have slashed those levies flat out, not this half‑measure charade that only pats the pockets of liberal think‑tanks.